Sharpening tip from a not-so-newbie
Welcome! / Forums / General Woodworking Discussions / Tools and Tool Maintenance/Restoration / Sharpening tip from a not-so-newbie
Tagged: sharpening
- This topic has 11 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 4 years, 5 months ago by
Flemming Aaberg.
-
AuthorPosts
-
Hi,
I’m posting this in case it helps anyone else in a similar position (@mark68 – your recent post is related I think).
When I started woodworking a couple of years ago I was fortunate to be able to order a set of EZE-LAP diamond stones, and built a sharpening station like Paul’s. I bought a Veritas Mk 2 sharpening jig.
I never got on with this setup, never got anything really sharp. I got “sharp” but never really sharp.
I always started on coarse, went to fine, then super fine, then strop. It always started out promisingly but always went off somehow.
And I was never able to freehand sharp, ever.
I have never been entirely happy with my EZE-LAP stones.
I’ve been switching out my EZE-LAP stones for DMT stones one at a time, and seeing how I got on.
I’ve now switched out the last stone and my sharpening has been transformed.
I’m getting things SHARP, very quickly, and am now able to freehand sharpen. It’s not pretty like Paul’s but it is at least sharp!
I’ve realized after some googling around that my EZE-LAP superfine stone is defective. My sharpening on the coarse and fine stones is actually fine, but if I take the tool to the super fine it gets scratched and dull.
There are many (not lots though) people online reporting similar experiences, with both EZE-LAP and DMT.
So, my tip for anyone in a similar position: don’t just assume that your diamond plates are perfect, and that the problem is you. It might well be a faulty plate.
One more tip while I’m here: don’t go back to coarse every time, fine or superfine may well be enough if you don’t have any nicks in the edge.
Darren.
A very timely post as I was on the verge of ordering EZE lap stones. Now I’m not too sure.
But you also say many people have also had the same problem with the DMT’s super fine.
I think I shall hold fire until more information is forthcoming. These stones aren’t cheap.
Thanks for the information.
29 April 2019 at 3:05 pm #557428Hi Darren
Thanks for the tip. Am thinking of buying the veritas mk2. Would you say it’s worth paying extra for it as opposed to a cheap eclipsed style honing guideSeajay,
These issues seem to appear periodically.
I generally don’t pay too close attention, but I don”t recall a single individual having contacting the manufacturer for advise or reconcillation of their problem.
Frankly, if I was experiencing a problem with a product or needed advise on an application, I’d start with the manufacturer rather than a forum.
Most companies are real interested in helping out and have staff to do so.
Best,
Craig1 May 2019 at 10:57 am #557663I love my Ezelap plates. I generally only need to use the finest and then strop. Like Paul says it really does only take about 1-2 minutes to resharpen during a job. I initially used a honing guide but now freehand sharpen and it is just magical.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.