19 December 2012 at 9:47 pm #5281
If I buy an extra blade for my veritas #4 smooth plane and hone it to a small radius would it work like a scrub plane? I’d set the frog so it would have a big mouth opening. I can buy some white oak and walnut that is 20% off but it is only skipped planed so I’d have to plane it smooth.
-Canada19 December 2012 at 10:15 pm #5284psiParticipant
I’d say that’s really not worth the bother. Not scrub-planing, but fiddling with the veritas which should stay as a fine smoother.
Attached is an image of my scrub plane and its blade. The blade is apparently self-made, a bit thicker than Stanley blade; no chip breaker. Width is much less that for the #4 blade (the other blade in picture). It’s a rough tool but it likes to eat wood, does that quite fast. I’m quite sure that you can source some older “coffin” for much cheaper than a suitable blade for a veritas #4.
Stupid is like stupid does, even here in rural Finland.20 December 2012 at 2:23 am #5293jbecwarParticipant
I would just get an old No 5 and put like a 8 inch radius on it. It would cost about the same and would save you from having to reconfigure your plane.
-James20 December 2012 at 5:57 am #5296AnonymousInactive
An old and effective work around regarding bulk stock removal simply involves skewing the iron laterally – adjust the lateral lever so it cuts heavily on one side of the mouth – and scrub the working surface diagonally to the grain while overlapping each stroke by half a plane’s width. Apart from the above method I’d simply keep a spare heavily cambered iron for a #5/#05 and use it whenever necessary. 😉20 December 2012 at 12:06 pm #5334
I don’t have a #5 but I have a veritas low angle jack plane. Would cambering a spare blade work in that?
-Canada20 December 2012 at 12:12 pm #5335AnonymousInactive
You need a much bigger camber on the blade / Iron to compensate for the low bedding angle, and it being bevel up20 December 2012 at 4:42 pm #5347Frank Vinkler, UKParticipant
If you have money to buy Veritas low angle jack, keep it tuned and spend tenner or two and buy an old No. 5 and dedicate it to hoggin’ . You will need only one scrub plane in your life, so it’s worth to have one. And the spare iron for 5 is definitely cheaper as well 😉
(there is ALWAYS reason to buy another plane, right?)20 December 2012 at 7:13 pm #5358AnonymousInactive
Like Frank said, I’d much rather throw funds at a cheap #5/#05 and give it a specific task, rather than needlessly cambering a comparatively expensive bevel up iron and tasking an expensive plane with scrub/roughing work. Scrub irons needn’t be expensive, plus a decent old #5 can be picked up (With iron and cap iron complete) for less than a new Veritas bevel up iron. 😉20 December 2012 at 7:25 pm #5360
Well I have to think about this. Maybe I should just look for a scrub plane.
-Canada20 December 2012 at 7:35 pm #5363AnonymousInactive
These make good scrub planes Dave 😉 Much of the time you’ll find scrubs are used to clean old or rough sawn timber to expose fresh surfaces. There must be something like the one nearest my #04 near your location.20 December 2012 at 7:37 pm #5367AnonymousInactive
I would go for a No. 5
It is traditionally used diagonal to the grain with a heavily cambered iron and a fairly coarse set, performing a similar function on sawn timber as the scrub plane does on riven boards – removing wind, cupping, bowing etc to leave a level furrowed surface that is then brought to final dimension and finished with other planes.
Like every thing it comes down to personal choice 🙂28 February 2013 at 1:21 pm #8661john baileyParticipant
I rescued a Handyman headed for tool heaven, rounded the edge, and it’s made a fine scrubber.28 February 2013 at 2:25 pm #8662jgust747Participant
I know that some are buying the HF #33 $9.99 plane and turning it into a scrub plane by just cambering the iron. No need to flatten the sole on a scrub plane.
Dallas, Texas28 February 2013 at 6:24 pm #8676robinhcParticipant
What about an old Craftsman #4 or #5 from eBay? Should make a great scrub plane and will be inexpensive because … well because no one wants them. I just saw a #5 for $26 ($10+$16 shipping) with no bids. Search for “craftsman hand plane #5”
Robin ... Richmond, Virginia, USA28 February 2013 at 7:38 pm #8680Gary HodginParticipant
As mentioned, you have several options. If you want to use your Veritas as a scrub, I’d just radius an extra blade, separate from your smoothing blade. You shouldn’t have to mess with the frog, assuming your plane has an adjustable mouth. I have a Veritas 4.5 and it has an adjustable mouth. Try leaving the frog alone and just open the mouth. Maybe it opens enough.
Ideally, you could have a dedicated scrub plane. I spent a lot of money and got the LN scrub. This was before Veritas came out with its version. The Veritas is significantly cheaper and is probably as good.
Prior to having the LN, I used a modern Stanley #4. It was one of first planes I owned and quite frankly it was more suited as a scrub plane than as a smooth plane. All it needed was a radius modification of the blade and a little backing off of the frog. It’s sole was no where near flat. A mouse could ski down either side of the hump right in front of the blade. However, a modified #4 works great as a scrub. Smaller and lighter than a number 5-like plane. Of course, a #5 works well too, but you already have a very nice #5. I’ve got the LN version of the BU jack plane and I reserve it for a little further down the line. Those planes are extremely versatile and easy to set up. Probably my most used plane.
I consider finding a cheap #4 on ebay or somewhere. Modify the blade and the frog and go to town. The other options are out there as well. If I found a better deal on a #5 I’d probably go that route. Seems #4s are usually cheaper the #5s in same condition.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.