46 comments on “Making a Wooden Spokeshave: Episode 2

  1. I completed all the steps from your first video, and waited for the second video with much anticipation. Now that I ‘e seen the second video, I am eager to complete my wooden spoke shave! Your way of teaching… “how To”… is so relaxed, it has given me confidence to try many of the procedures you have taught. I am now at a point in my woodworking hobby where I prefer using hand tools, especially ones I have made. I personally would like to thank you for all that you have taught me. Gary.

  2. wonderful project and so essential , too. This made my day for some month ahead !!!!

    Please tell us, Paul : how about curved soles ? I imagine you would give it a good hammer blow whilst the iron reposes on it’s extremities. Is that right? and are curved sole useful anyway?

    Thanks anyway !!!

  3. I just completed my spoke shave. I would like to say “it works awesome! It actually works better than the Stanley I used to shape it. I whole heartedly suggest this project. It was fun to make and will be funner to use. Thanks Paul.
    Gary Mercer.

  4. Thank you for the excellent video Paul. I love making handtools for wood working and this is one design I particularly like, especially the micro adjustment of the blade.
    I have a number of wooden spokeshaves made in boxwood and beech, all of which are such a joy to use. I also have a couple with the cast iron bodies which are not so pleasureable.
    I have difficulty understanding why tool makers like Stanley transitioned to making them from cast iron. They’re so clumsy and unrefined, even feel brutal in their use compared with the light finely crafted wooden devices I have.
    A great project for every woodworker to enjoy.

  5. I think this has to be one of the most simple of all woodworking tools, which may be why I have the least skill with it. The more simple=more skilled required. Paul makes it look easy.

  6. What a beautiful video and lovely spokeshave. I found this so calming to watch and yet excited to try myself. What a wonderful legacy to give to the world. Thank you 🙂

  7. Once again just a perfect lesson. Just the length and simple to follow. I have 4 or 5 shaves already so I don’t see me making this one so but it was still very informative as to lay-out and fitting. I’ve got and use bothe steel and wood shaves. Don’t really get the whole elegant to use thing. They all work well if sharp and set up properly.

  8. Anyone like to comment on the different types of wood suitable for this. At the moment I have Ash, Oak, Cherry, Walnut and Pine lying around.

    I would think ash or oak would do as they are both hard and tough wood.

    • Hej Kjell,

      If you are OK with the response from a dabbler, I would say it’s a just question with a very complicated answer.

      Assuming you are in Norway, the ranking would be Ash > Walnut > Oak > Cherry, with pine as a dark horse. If, on the other hand, you are located in North America, it will be Ash > Walnut/Oak > Cherry, with pine as a more remote dark horse.

      Basically, what this spokeshave calls for is wood that does not flex under load, and does not break when the load point of flexing is reached. The hardness, i.e. the force necessary to impact/dent the wood, is not that critical. Thus, Scandinavian Scots Pine (Pinus Sylvestris) would the first choice, if that’s what you have available, because it grows so slowly. The opposite applies for the four hardwoods: the faster they grow the less elasticity, with variations explained by the nature of their pores. Hence, albeit that winters can be very cold, as the growth period is longer in much of North America (NY on the same latitude as Naples), an American white Oak is more resistant to flexing than an European, even though the latter might be harder. A slow-grown long-leaf pine (Pinus palustris [very rare, I think]) will surpass all the discussed ones. Only European beech would be better.

      Finally and probably most important, the wood should have straight grain along all four sides (faces and long edges). Cross running grain will break much more easily, with the associated risk of injury.

      Best
      Sven-Olof

      • I wonder how silver birch would fare here, or maybe rowan (rönnträ). Both are known to be good for tool handles traditionally.

        Seems spokeshaves are put under similar stresses as tool and axe handles. Working from that logic, maybe hickory would be a good choice for a spokeshave?

        I suppose pine is suitable but I just wouldn’t want a tool made from one, don’t get me wrong I do 99% of my work in pine and fir, but I get tired of it, and it’s not as pleasant to work with as hardwood IMO.

        I currently have a few small pieces of walnut, oak and ash in my workshop, I believe I will try ash for my first wooden spokeshave.

        • Handles in general should flex before they break, I suppose. That would make rowan useful, and silver birch even more so. There might be a snag though: a spokeshave glides along a surface. I have no idea if that’s relevant given that it’s such a narrow tool, but I suspect that the higher smoothness of lignum vitae (pockenholz) made it preferable above hickory for plane making.

          There are videos on making bench planes from black walnut, so the alternatives are probably many, with beech perhaps most out of tradition?
          /soj

          • I do live in Norway Sven-Olof, but most of the hardwood sold for furniture is imported, so all the mentioned wood types are from the USA.

            As you mention in your reply, the breaking strength is probably best for and worst for cherry (leaving pine out of it). I was also thinking a bit along the line of how the wood wears when you rub it against a workpiece a few years.

            Anyway, it’s not that big project, and any failures only accelerates learning. I’ll probably try with the ash. Or maybe I can find a big enough log og birch in the wood shed.

  9. Hi Paul,
    Love your videos and the way the skill of a craftsman of fifty years shows through.
    I’ve been watching you for about two years now and would like to make a comment about your description while heat treating. Please don’t take this as a criticism, but as a point of technical correction.
    Let me preface this with the statement that I’ve been a professional blacksmith for as long as you’ve been working wood.
    In a couple of your videos when you are heat treating tool steel you first harden the piece and then mention that you are going to “anneal” it or that it could be annealed.The process of annealing is to heat the piece of steel above the critical temperature or “nonmagnetic” and allow it to cool slowly. This process ( for most steels ) brings the steel to it’s softest hardness possible. The term you should be using is “temper”.
    To Temper a steel is to draw some of the harness out of the fully hardened steel by heating to a predetermined temperature, say 300* F and stop at that point. This removes some of the brittleness of the hardening process but still allows the steal to retain some other property’s like edge retention for a cutting tool or elasticity for say a spring.
    I only mention this because a student or viewer of your videos who might delve further into the heat treating process on the web or the library might get confused when trying to follow your processes as you describe them.

    Yours Helpfully intended,
    Dick Sargent

  10. I did the spokeshave! Just without adjusters.
    I want to make the cam clamps also but I don’t have 1/8” chisel to chop the recess for the bar can I use the stock I have left from making the spokeshave blade to make a 1/8” chisel? Thanks.

Privacy Notice
You must enter certain information to comment on this page. We take the handling of personal information seriously and appreciate your trust in us. Our Privacy Policy sets out important information about us and how we use and protect your personal data and it also explains your legal rights in respect of it. Please click here to read it before you comment.

If you are having problems with viewing the video, or you have any other technical problem, please don’t use the comments, instead contact us here

Leave a Reply